Pizza restaurants

Mama Mia Pizzeria

4.3 278 reviews 3:00 AM - 9:00 PM 128 Lebby St, Pelzer, SC 29669, United States

Discover this place

Mama Mia Pizzeria, located at 128 Lebby St, Pelzer, SC, has earned a stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike. Customers rave about the authentic flavors and the welcoming atmosphere provided by the owners, who have mastered the art of pizza-making over many years. Salina Arrington describes the Philly cheese steak pizza as "delicious," noting the perfectly crafted dough that rivals any pizza she's had in 8 years, even comparing it favorably to her beloved Jersey pies.

Lyzzie Lynn resonates with the hand-crafted quality, expressing her admiration for the Italian Sausage sub and the accompanying Mac n cheese bites and pepperoni rolls, which are laden with cheesy goodness. Meanwhile, David Simmons praises the Stromboli for its crisp crust and fresh ingredients, echoing the sentiments of many regarding the personable service. So much so that Kay Dee considers it a family staple, consistently pleased with everything from wings to desserts. Emz particularly highlights the irresistible pizza knots and sweet tea, reaffirming that Mama Mia's is a restaurant worth weekly visits.

Overall, Mama Mia Pizzeria is a must-try destination where outstanding flavors and warm, attentive service leave guests returning for more.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Mama Mia Pizzeria before visiting.

Reviews for Mama Mia Pizzeria

4.3

278 reviews

100%

24%

10%

Review highlights

Based on 278 reviews

Mama Mia Pizzeria in Pelzer has garnered consistent praise for its flavorful, house-made dishes and inviting atmosphere. Reviewers frequently highlight the quality and freshness of the ingredients, noting standout items like the pizza dough, subs, and signature pepperoni rolls. The menu variety, including wings, desserts, and other comfort foods, is well-received, appealing to different tastes. Customers also appreciate the attentive and friendly service, with staff often recognized for their willingness to address any issues promptly and courteously. The combination of reasonable pricing, a welcoming environment, and reliably delicious food has made Mama Mia Pizzeria a favored local destination and a frequent repeat choice for many patrons in the region.

Salina Arrington

Jun 17, 2025

I tried the Philly cheese steak pizza... delicious!!! The dough was so tasty and just right! I'm from Jersey and live in Greer, best pizza i had in 8 years!!!! I would totally ride to Pelszer again for Mama Mia's pizza....

Lyzzie Lynn

Jun 02, 2025

Amazing place! You can tell the food is house made , everything we ordered had amazing flavor . Me and my husband got a 12’ Italian Sausage sub and shared that, with Mac n cheese bites & pepperoni rolls the Mac and cheese bites were fresh and well cooked , pepperoni rolls were cheesy and delicious with both ranch and pizza sauces, the sandwich was filling, covered in cheese and filled amazingly with ingredients. We loved everything and left with a smile ! This is a must try little place! 10/10

David Simmons

May 01, 2025

This place was recommended to me years ago by a friend who claims this is the best pizza in the upstate. Now, I will say, I agree. The Stromboli crust was perfectly crisp and savory, and the ingredients were fresh and very tasty. The owners have been in business for many years and are friendly and took time to talk with me about their business and the area. I will definitely return and wish I had tried this place sooner.

Kay Dee

Apr 28, 2025

I’ve had about everything on the menu it’s always great the wings and pizzas, subs, desserts and bread. It’s all great. They have amazing customer service and great prices I’m always pleased an if ever made a mistake they fix it and own up and make it right. One of my favorite family go to spots. All around amazing place!

emz

Apr 23, 2025

Pizza knots (pepperoni rolls) are my absolute favorite. We go at least once a week. The sweet tea is the best you'll find at a restaurant around here.

Emily M.

Apr 19, 2025

The best pizza my family has ever had! Highly recommend. I had the chicken bbq pizza and it was so good. Next time we come to Greenville we will be stopping here again!

Ken Morrill

Apr 14, 2025

If you’re looking for a great stromboli, look no further! Mama Mia’s has excellent Italian food in a home town atmosphere. I have walked in several times, ordered and sat down, and within 10 minutes was served delicious food (usually a pepperoni and black olive stromboli). Give them a shot! You’ll be so happy you did!

Hector Rodriguez

Mar 22, 2025

First time trying their pizza and was not disappointed! Something about the sauce really made the pizza stand out and delicious. Everything was nice proportional. Female employee was very nice and polite. Will definitely be coming back.